Best Dog Training Collars 2020: Train Your Dog without Hassle
Author Robert Herrera Reading 1 min Published by
An electric dog training collar today is considered the most advanced tool of dogs’ behavior correction. Though it is often referred to as a dog training shock collar, it doesn’t cause any harm or stress to a dog. On the contrary, it has a relatively gentle action while being very effective. If used correctly, a professional dog training collar helps to achieve noticeable results in training in short time.
Table of Contents:
What is an E-Collar, and Who Needs It?
Top-Rated Dog Training Collars 2018: a Comparative Chart
Benefits of Training Collars for Dogs
Things to Consider When Buying a Training Collar
How We Picked out the Best Dog Training Collar 2018
Top-11 Dog Training Collars 2018: Our Choice
1. SportDOG Brand 425 Family Remote Trainers
2. Petrainer PET998DBB2 100% Waterproof and Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar
3. HISEASUN Remote Dog Training Collar
4. iPets PET619S 100% Waterproof & Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar
5. Dog Training Collar, PESTON Shock Collar
6. PetTech Remote Controlled Dog Training Collar
7. ProCollar Dog Training Collar
8. PetSafe Yard & Park Dog Training Collar
9. TBI Pro Dog Shock Training Collar
10. Naturepets Remote Dog Training Collar
11. Dog Care Dog Training Collar
12. PATPET Shock Collar for Dogs with Remote Waterproof Dog Training Collar Rechargeable w/3 Training Modes
13. Shock Collar for Dogs - IPX7 Waterproof Dog Shock Collar with Remote IPX5 3000ft Range Dog Training Collar Fast Training Effect for Dog
14. Pawious Dog Training Collar with Remote [Newest] - Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar for Small Medium and Large Dogs | Long Range up to 1600ft, Waterproof, E-Collar
Dogs’ Training at a Glance: Only Facts
How to Make Most of a Training Collar without Doing Harm to a Dog
Frequently Asked Questions
Verdict and Recommendations
First of all, let’s answer the question: what is an e-collar for dog training? Basically, it is an electronic device, consisting of two blocks: a collar itself and a remote. It is equipped with two prong contacts that touch a dog’s skin, and a receiver, while a remote serves a transmitter. A dog owner pushes a button on a remote, and a dog feels an electric shock, which is too weak to make any harm, and strong enough to cause a certain discomfort. The strength of the discharge can be regulated by a trainer. This minor electric shock acts as a special form of punishment for a dog that behaves improperly.
Does every dog owner need a training collar for its dog? Well, it depends. You can, without a doubt, consider the possibility of buying a dog training collar with remote in the following cases:
The safety and effectiveness of e-collars have been repeatedly proved by specialists. It is also proved by numerous best dog training collar reviews. To make the most of this device one needs to know how to use a dog training collar properly. It is equally important to understand what particular type of a device suits your dog best.
There are various subtypes of wireless collars – those designed specially for the use by professional trainers and those for hunting dogs. Also, there are special anti-barking models that are activated automatically when a dog starts barking. Finally, there are collars working as invisible fences or boundaries when it’s necessary to train a dog to stay within the borders of a non-fenced territory, for example, a yard. The most popular models are multi-purpose remotely controlled collars for training a dog to follow orders at a distance. They can be equipped with some additional features:
There are waterproof models that are used under extreme environmental conditions, and special variations for very big and small breeds. The assortment is really impressive. You can rely on three main criteria: the intended use, the size of the dog, and extra features.
|SportDOG Brand 425|
|PESTON Shock Collar|
|PetTech Dog Training Collar|
|ProCollar Dog Training Collar|
|PetSafe Yard & Park|
|Naturepets Remote Dog Training Collar|
|Dog Care training collar|
The attitude toward training collars is controversial: some people associate them with violence and animal abuse. Specialists believe that this smart equipment has a lot of benefits in the long-term perspective. Here are some of them.
Dogs express their joy by jumping on their beloved people. If a dog is large and heavy, or it jumps on kids, or it is muddy, or it jumps on other people (for example, guests) and frightens them, this behavior needs correction. Using of a training collar is the best way to prevent jumping.
Dogs can bark and howl for various reasons. Sometimes, continuous barking can be very annoying, especially if you live in an apartment, not in a single-family house. In this case, an anti-bark training collar is the best (not to say the only) solution.
Some dogs tend to chew furniture, scratch walls, drop cookware and small household items on the floor, and do other destructive things. With the help of training equipment, you’ll explain your four-legged friend what kind of behavior is unacceptable.
Aggressive dogs cause a lot of troubles to both their owners and other people. It is crucial to stop aggression in pups as soon as possible. Conventional methods sometimes don’t work: training collars give positive results in the majority of cases.
For whatever reason you are buying a training collar, it is important to choose the right model. An improper or unsuitable unit will cause discomfort to the pet. To get the desired result without making harm to your pup rely on the following basic criteria.
It goes without saying that the collar must correspond to the size of a dog. Most models are adjustable. And still, try to choose small and lightweight options for smaller breeds, and heavier, thicker (and more durable) variations for larger breeds. Both very large and very small sizes will cause discomfort to a pet.
It depends on where you are going to train a dog: at home, in the yard, or in the open space. The range of operation of good collars can reach 400-500 yards, which is enough for the training of hunting and working dogs. For home training, models with a smaller range will do.
Dog training collars commonly come with rechargeable batteries. The battery life can vary from 1 day to 2 months. If you are intending to go hunting or hiking with a dog, choose the options with the maximum battery life and don’t forget about spare batteries.
Any electric collar for an outdoor dog must be waterproof for the sake of safety. For indoor dogs training, this feature is not mandatory. Keep in mind that waterproof is not a synonym of water-resistant. If you need the best protection from water (e.g. if your pup is going to swim in the river), choose only waterproof models.
To correct a dog’s behavior, stimulation with a weak electric shock is used. Most models allow adjusting the shock intensity. On the top of it, many models offer additional options – vibration and tone, which are commonly used as warning or preventive stimulation. Every time a dog demonstrates undesired behavior, the trainer warns it with vibration or beeping. If it doesn’t stop, electric shock is used. Frequently, dogs start to react properly on preventive stimulation soon, and electric shock becomes unnecessary.
Our ranking of the best models of e-collars for dogs is based on numerous dog training collar reviews of real customers and experts in dog training. But reviews are not the only criterion. To choose the leaders we thoroughly compared features of the chosen models, trying to be as unbiased as possible. In particular, we analyzed such features as:
The result of this comprehensive analysis is a list of eleven best electronic dog training collar models of the year 2018. It’s for you to decide what particular model to choose for your dog. Anyway, having bought any of the described brands, you may be assured of its high quality and reliability.
Here is a list of seven top dog training collar models that were chosen based on multiple criteria. They are different in terms of features and price, but they are all highly estimated by both dog owners and professional trainers. Now it’s your turn to choose the best item for your canine companion.
This is a rechargeable dog training collar with a handful of really useful features. The device can be used for up to three dogs training simultaneously (two additional collars need to be bought separately). It has a lot of training modes, including the continuous and momentary shock stimulation, vibration and beep tone.
It is slightly more expensive than average, but it is worthy of it! The unit is exceptionally well-made, compact, and easy to set up. It works consistently and without any glitches. It is versatile and flexible enough, though there are only 7 correction levels.
This is another great wireless dog training collar – safe, versatile, and affordable. The set comes with two collars included that can be used simultaneously on two dogs. The key features of this Petrainer are a perfect adjustability due to 100 levels of the signal strength and a fully waterproof receiver.
If you are not a professional dog trainer or a hunter; if you are not going to train your pups under the extreme conditions, this Petrainer collar is what you need. It is relatively cheap and easy to use. With an average range of operation, it will do for occasional walks in the park or training in a yard. That said, we don’t like its plastic finish.
HISEASUN is one more contender for the title of the best training collar for dogs. The supply package includes two soft silicon collars with receivers and a transmitter featuring nice LED-backlit displays. It sets a stable connection at the distance of up to 875 yards in an open space with no obstacles.
It is not for aggressive, very stubborn or very large dogs because its stimulation intensity is slightly less intensive than average. That said, it is a decent medium-priced option that does its job pretty well.
iPets PET619S is another waterproof dog training collar with quite a standard set of features. It has 3 modes (shock, vibration, and tone), 100 levels of stimulation to choose from, and a good range of up to 330 yards. There is no light mode, and the supply package includes only one collar.
We have two minor complaints about this model: the battery life is average, and the buttons are prone to accidental pressing. Otherwise, it is a good training solution. It’s a pity that only one collar is included.
PESTON offers an entry-level solution for dogs’ behavior correction. This model has a range of 330 yards, which is enough for basic training in a yard or in a park, and quite standard features. 100 levels of stimulation provide a gentle and precise regulation of the signal strength.
Despite its entry-level price, the device works pretty well. We love its intuitive layout and large buttons of three different colors. It is really simple and easy to use.
PetTech is one of the best dog training collar models, according to the expert opinion. It features an impressive range of 400 yards and 4 different stimulation modes: shock, vibration, tone, and light. It suits most small and big breeds and can be adjusted for dogs from 10 to 100 pounds. The PetTech remote controlled dog training collar is frequently chosen by professional trainers.
This e-collar has met all the expectations – it works exactly as it should, without any problems. The only small complaint is a lack of the second collar.
Many customers consider ProCollar to the best dog walking training collar. Firstly, it can maintain a stable connection at the distance of up to 800 yards in an open space. Secondly, it weather-resistant, which means you can walk on a rainy day. Thirdly, it has minimum buttons and allows to use the needed mode directly, without switching from one mode to another.
We love the collar quality – it is nylon instead of plastic. It is easily adjusted and relatively lightweight, so it won’t cause discomfort even o smaller pups. Spare collars are not sold separately – it is a sort of a disappointment.
PetSafe manufactures great pet products, and its Yard & Park collar is no exception. With an impressive range of 400 yards, 8 stimulation levels, waterproof construction and a fully adjustable collar, the device will suit for most dogs. Train your pup easily in the yard, in the park, or in the open space.
We love the overall product’s quality but we are not crazy about the transmitter design. It lacks a display, and a dial for the stimulation level correction is a sort of bulky and not very convenient.
It is not for nothing that the new TBI Pro training collar is currently one of the Amazon’s best-sellers. With an increased range of 500 yards, a long-standing battery, four types of stimulation available, and an excellent adjustability, it is the best in its price range. The collar can be adjusted for the dogs from 8 to 100 lbs. It offers 100 intensity levels for precise and accurate stimulation.
What makes this model stand out of the crowd is that it’s made of a leather-like material – more durable and pleasant to touch than usual plastic. Thanks to its large intuitive buttons and a bright display, it is very easy to use. The battery life is beyond the praise.
Naturpets training collar is an affordable option with a pleasant set of features and a good adjustability. It offers up to 100 intensity levels and three basic modes of stimulation – shock, sound, and vibration. The operation range of the device is 330 yards – enough for a regular training in the yard or in the park. The collar is waterproof, which is important for outdoor doggies training.
At first sight, the collar seems to be a cheap and flimsy stuff. But after some testing, we can say that it costs its money. The device works consistently irrespective of the landscape and weather conditions. It takes some time to make the initial setting of the optimal signal strength. When set-up it works as needed.
This training set offers a standard pack of features: three modes of stimulation with a possibility of intensity adjusting from 1 to 99 and a remote control at the distance of up to 330 yards. Also, it has a couple of unique solutions. The first is the keypad lock that prevents accidental shock. The second one is an opportunity of connecting up to 9 collars to one transmitter.
It is a top pick for everyone who needs to train several dogs simultaneously. While most sets allow up to 2 or 3 connections, Dog Care offers enormous 9 collars connected to one transmitter.
PATPET professional training collars are safe, easy to use, and effective. With 16 shock levels, 8 vibration levels, and a beep mode, they provide enough versatility and suit for training dogs of different sensitivity. The battery life is impressive: up to 12 days for a collar and up to 56 days for a remote. With a reach range of up to 1000 feet, you can train your dog almost anywhere you want.
The collar has a lot to be loved for. It is really easy to use while being fully adjustable. One of the minor drawbacks is that the remote is always on; you just need to wake it up after a long pause by tapping any button.
This is another option by PATPET with some premium features to enjoy. If compared to older versions, the reach range has increased up to 3000 feet, which allows you to train your pup in the park or even in the forest. The receiver is completely waterproof (IPX7 standard). The battery life is up to 10 days in the receiver and up to 20 days in a remote.
The collar works exactly as advertised, which is proven by the successful experience of 1000+ customers. One remote can be connected to two collars simultaneously; switching between the collars is very easy. The only small complaint is no battery indicator on both the remote and the receiver.
If you are looking for a rechargeable waterproof training collar for everyday use, this option by Pawious is just what you need. With its sleek ergonomic design and a decent reach range of 1600 feet, it is really helpful for those engaged in dog training. The quick charge feature lets recharge the transmitter or the receiver just within an hour. With 9 levels of static correction and 5 levels of vibration, it offers enough versatility in terms of stimulation.
All in all, this training collar is definitely a good value for money. It is lightweight, easy to use, and fully adjustable to fit all dog breeds. The quick charge feature is nice to have too. We’d like the transmitter to be a bit larger, as its all-black buttons are placed too close to each other, which is not very convenient.
Sometimes, in their remote dog training collar reviews, customers write that this training equipment doesn’t work for their dogs, or, what is even worse, that they hurt their pets with it. In the majority of cases, the reason for it is the improper use of the device. That is why don’t be lazy to read an instruction before using a collar and adhere to some basic rules.
Choose a lightweight and small dog training collar for small breeds and a larger training collar for large dog breeds. Most models allow adjusting, and still, you need to be very cautious, especially if your canine is small. If a collar is heavy, it will cause a serious discomfort to the pet, and can even lead to the neck trauma. Also, it must not be tight because an excessive pressure will increase the discomfort.
A training collar must not be worn for more than 8 hours without breaks. Some models allow up to 12 hours of continuous using, but it is acceptable for trained dogs of relatively large breeds only. If your pet has to wear a collar all day long, try to change its position on the neck every 1-2 hours.
Keep in mind that electronic training collars are intended for the use only with special remote transmitters. Never try to attach a usual leash to an e-collar. Firstly, you can break the device. Secondly, you will hurt your dog.
A: All the training collars have a similar mechanism of action. A trainer presses a button on the remote every time a dog behaves improperly. The dog gets an electric shock – harmless but unpleasant. After several attempts of wrong actions resulting in stimulation, the pet’s behavior corrects.
A: No, it won’t. The shock is weak to make a real harm to a pet (wound or kill it). That said, it can be painful if you choose an inadequate intensity of stimulation. If you are not sure what intensity level to use, start from the weakest possible option an hen gradually increase it if needed.
A: Yes, absolutely, at least, until you use them correctly. Make sure you’ve read the instruction before you put an e-collar on your pup.
A: Specialists recommend dog owners start e-collar training at the age of 6 months. However, some puppies, especially those of large breeds, are ready for this at the age of 4 months. But, regardless of your decision, the process must be slow. Don’t start with electric shock correction. In the beginning, just let your puppy get used to wearing a collar. Start training from 10-20 minutes per day and then increase the time gradually.
A: Wearing a collar in non-public areas is not mandatory. Even though some dogs may feel quite comfortable wearing their collars constantly it's recommended to take it off occasionally to check the dog for any signs of damage. You see, constantly wearing a collar can damage a dog's skin and fur on his neck. If you notice any collar-related issue, that may indicate the collar is too tight for the pet, and you should try a more comfortable one. So, a dog should not wear its collar all the time. Walking without a collar on at home is recommended.
Now, after we’ve reviewed popular models of dog’s e-collars, let’s try to find an answer to the question: what is the best dog training collar? You could notice that many of them have very similar features, so it’s not an easy affair to choose the only leader. The choice will also depend on your personal preferences. For example, if you are looking for the best waterproof dog training collar, consider the SportDOG model, which is fully submersible up to 25 feet. Your dog can swim in it and walk in the rain as long as needed.
Our top choice is the PetTech dog training collar with an impressive range of 400 yards, 4 different modes of stimulation and a lifetime warranty from the manufacturer. It is chosen by professional dog trainers, and it is a great value for the money.